Roblox guide

MM2 Value List: Most Valuable Items Ranked

What is your knife actually worth, and what should you trade for?

5 min read8 sectionsUpdated August 2026
MM2 value tiers from Ancient and Vintage down to common Godly weapons

Trading is the real endgame of Murder Mystery 2, and knowing what your items are worth is the difference between building a great inventory and getting scammed out of it.

MM2 is one of the biggest games on Roblox, with over 27 billion visits, and its trading economy has been running for years. Values move constantly as items retire and new ones drop.

This guide explains the real value tiers, shows the top items in each, and teaches you what actually drives a price. New here? Our MM2 wiki covers the basics, and the MM2 codes page lists free rewards.

The Quick Answer

The most valuable items are the Ancients (like Batwing and Nik's Scythe) and the Vintages (like Cowboy and Ghost), because only 19 and 9 of them exist. After that come Chromas, then Tier 0 Godlies like the Seer family. Everything else is a long way down.

Not everything in this game can be traded. Our MM2 maps guide covers all 67 maps, including the 13 that were removed and the 10 that never came out at all.

Not everything in MM2 is about trading. Our MM2 Powers guide covers the 10 shop abilities you buy outright with Coins or Diamonds, never traded.

Read This Before You Trust Any Value List

MM2 values change every single day. On one recent day alone, Chroma Evergreen dropped by 1,000 value while Chroma Sunrise went up by 150.

That is why we do not print a big list of hard numbers here. Any guide that does is out of date within a week. Instead, this page teaches you the tiers and the six things that actually drive a price, so you can read a live value tracker yourself and never get lowballed.

The Real MM2 Value Tiers

Here is how the game actually ranks its weapons, straight from its own data, and what that means for value.

TierWhat it isWhat it is worth
AncientThe rarest tier in the game, one step above Godly. Only 19 exist.Top of the value list. Batwing, Nik's Scythe, and Icewing sit here.
VintageThe original weapons from the game's early days. Only 9 exist and none drop anymore.Extremely valuable because supply is frozen forever.
ChromaShimmering event versions of Godly weapons. There are 69 of them.Worth far more than the normal Godly they are based on.
GodlyThe main collectible tier, with 120 weapons (81 knives, 39 guns).Value swings hugely depending on its internal tier, from Seer down to common box Godlies.
LegendaryOne step below Godly. Obtainable from boxes.Low value. Useful for building up to a Godly trade, not much else.
Rare / Uncommon / CommonThe everyday weapons you unbox constantly.Almost no trade value. Do not expect anything for these.

The Godly Tier System Most Guides Miss

Here is something almost no value list tells you: the game sorts its 120 Godly weapons into four internal tiers, from Tier 0 down to Tier 3. This is the real hierarchy behind Godly prices.

Godly tierHow manyExamplesWhat it means
Tier 08 weaponsSeer, Blue Seer, Red Seer, Purple Seer, Orange Seer, Yellow SeerThe most exclusive Godlies in the game. The Seer family is craft-or-trade only, never unboxed.
Tier 132 weaponsDeathshard, Fang, Saw, Tides, Eternal (I to IV), Hallow's Edge, Ice DragonHigh-tier Godlies. Mostly event or limited items that no longer drop, which keeps values strong.
Tier 241 weaponsGemstone, Darkbringer, and most mid box GodliesThe middle of the pack. Still tradeable, but far more common.
Tier 336 weaponsThe most common box GodliesThe bottom of the Godly ladder. Easy to unbox, so values stay low.

So when someone offers you "a Godly for a Godly," check the tier first. A Tier 0 Seer and a Tier 3 box Godly are not remotely the same trade.

Every Ancient and Vintage Item

These are the two rarest categories in the game, and the full lists are short. If you own any of these, you are holding real value.

CategoryHow manyThe complete list
Ancient19 itemsBatwing, Nik's Scythe, Icewing, Elderwood Scythe, Logchopper, Hallowscythe, Icebreaker, Harvester, Reaver, Swirly Axe, Icepiercer, Icecrusher, Traveler's Axe, Gingerscope, Gingerscythe, Vampire's Axe, Celestial, Synthwave, Flames
Vintage9 itemsCowboy, Splitter, Ghost, Phaser, Prince, Shadow, Golden, Blood, America
The six things that actually drive an MM2 item's value
Value is not random. These six things decide it.

What Actually Drives an Item's Value

Once you understand these six things, you can judge any item yourself, even a brand new one nobody has priced yet.

DriverHow it works
SupplyHow many exist in the game. Fewer copies always means a higher value.
Retired or still droppableIf an item can still be unboxed, its supply keeps growing and its value slowly falls. Retired items are frozen.
Event exclusivityItems from a past Halloween, Christmas, or Summer event cannot come back, so they hold value well.
Chroma statusA Chroma version of a Godly is always worth much more than the plain version.
Godly tierThe game's own internal tier (0 to 3). A Tier 0 Seer and a Tier 3 box Godly are worlds apart.
DemandWhat people actually want right now. This is the part that swings week to week.

What to Trade For, Stage by Stage

Where you areTrade towardWhy
Just starting outA cheap GodlyGet any Godly first. It is your ticket into real trading.
Building upA Tier 1 GodlyTrade several low Godlies up into one Tier 1 like Hallow's Edge.
Mid-gameA ChromaChromas hold value better than most Godlies and are easy to re-trade.
EndgameAn Ancient or VintageBatwing, Icewing, or any Vintage. This is the top of the ladder.
Best long-term holdA retired event itemSupply is frozen forever, so it will not get devalued by new drops.
What to avoidOverpaying on hypeNew items spike then settle. Do not trade an Ancient for a fad.

How to Trade Safely

  • Never accept a trade you feel rushed into. Scammers push hard to stop you checking a value list.
  • Check the exact item name. Chroma versions and plain versions look similar but are worth wildly different amounts.
  • Look at the Godly tier before agreeing to a Godly-for-Godly swap.
  • Nobody legitimate needs your password or asks you to go first for a "trusted" trade. That is always a scam.
  • Check a live value tracker right before you confirm, since prices moved this week.

MM2 still gets regular updates and events, and every new event adds items that shift the market. The tiers on this page are stable, but individual prices are not. Grab free rewards on the MM2 codes page while you build your inventory.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers from this guide.

01

What is the most valuable item in MM2?

An Ancient weapon, like Batwing or Nik's Scythe. There are only 19 Ancients in the entire game, which puts them at the very top of the value list.

02

What are Vintage items worth?

A lot. There are only 9 Vintage weapons (Cowboy, Splitter, Ghost, Phaser, Prince, Shadow, Golden, Blood, America), and none of them drop anymore, so their supply is frozen forever.

03

Is a Seer valuable?

Yes. The Seer family sits in Tier 0, the most exclusive Godly tier in the game, and it can only be crafted or traded, never unboxed.

04

Why do MM2 values keep changing?

Because supply and demand move constantly. Items retire, new ones drop, and hype shifts. Values can change day to day, so always check a live tracker before a big trade.

05

What is the difference between a Godly and a Chroma?

A Chroma is a shimmering event version of a Godly weapon. There are 69 of them, and a Chroma is always worth considerably more than the plain Godly it is based on.

06

Does MM2 have codes?

Yes. Check our MM2 codes page for the current list. Codes usually give free knives or coins.

Now go trade smart

You know the real tiers, the hidden Godly ranking, and the six things that set a price. For the basics, read our MM2 wiki. Grab free items on the MM2 codes page, and check the MM2 script page too.

New to the game? Learn how to throw a knife as the Murderer.

Want one instead of just knowing its price? Our guide to getting a godly covers the real box odds and the crafting route that is guaranteed.

More guides

Keep going with these.

See all guides

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

Keep exploring

More free stuff for your Roblox account.